The Pittsburgh Steelers are at a crossroads in their quarterback search for the 2025 season. Rumors about Aaron Rodgers potentially joining the team have dominated the NFL news, but it’s crucial for the Steelers to have a backup plan in place. The prospect of Rodgers wearing the black and gold is thrilling, but it remains uncertain. Should this high-profile deal fall through, the Steelers need to pivot and explore other quarterback options that could guide them back to playoff contention. In this article, we’ll dive into the current situation with the Steelers’ quarterbacks, why Aaron Rodgers might not sign, and which three quarterbacks would be ideal targets for Pittsburgh if Rodgers fails to join.
The Current State of the Steelers’ Quarterback Position
The Steelers currently have Kenny Pickett, Mitch Trubisky, and Mason Rudolph on their quarterback roster. While Pickett showed promise in his rookie season, it is clear that he is still a work in progress. His performances have been mixed, and despite flashes of brilliance, his consistency as a starting QB remains uncertain. If the Steelers are serious about competing for championships, they need to ensure they have a reliable, seasoned quarterback under center.
Mason Rudolph has been with the Steelers for several seasons now, but he has only had limited opportunities to start. Though capable in certain situations, he hasn’t proven to be the long-term solution the Steelers are looking for. Mitch Trubisky, who was signed to provide a veteran presence, has also failed to stand out as a franchise quarterback. Although he has experience as a starter in the NFL, Trubisky’s inconsistent play raises questions about his future in Pittsburgh. The Steelers are clearly seeking a quarterback who can elevate the offense, and if Aaron Rodgers doesn’t make his way to Pittsburgh, they will need to explore other options to fill the void.
Why the Aaron Rodgers Deal Might Fail
Aaron Rodgers has been linked to the Pittsburgh Steelers for much of the offseason, but there are several factors that could prevent him from signing with the team. One major hurdle is the salary cap. Rodgers, a veteran quarterback with a hefty contract, could place a significant strain on the Steelers’ cap space. Pittsburgh is already working within tight financial constraints, and committing to Rodgers’ salary could limit their ability to build a complete team around him.
In addition to the financial challenges, there are other factors that could influence Rodgers’ decision. At 40 years old, Rodgers may prioritize team stability and playoff potential in his decision. While the Steelers boast a strong defense, their offense is still evolving. Rodgers might prefer a team with more established offensive weapons and a ready-made Super Bowl contender. Finally, there’s the personal element. Rodgers has a history of being selective about his teams, and the Steelers may not be at the top of his list. Given all these uncertainties, the Steelers must be prepared for the possibility that the Rodgers deal will fall through.
Kirk Cousins: A Proven Veteran with Consistent Performance
If the Steelers miss out on Aaron Rodgers, Kirk Cousins should be a prime target. Cousins is a proven veteran with a history of solid performance. Over the last few seasons, Cousins has consistently thrown for over 4,000 yards, making him one of the most reliable quarterbacks in the league. While his teams haven’t always gone deep in the playoffs, Cousins has proven himself capable of leading an offense and putting up impressive numbers in regular-season play.
Cousins’ consistency and ability to make all the necessary throws would provide the Steelers with a steady presence under center. With the Steelers’ strong defense and a promising young receiving corps, Cousins could be the catalyst needed to get Pittsburgh back to the postseason. He’s an experienced leader who could step in and quickly adapt to the Steelers’ system. Furthermore, Cousins has experience in high-pressure games, making him a great fit for a team like the Steelers, who are looking to make a push for a championship.
Derek Carr: A Strong Arm and Leadership Potential
Derek Carr is another quarterback who could be a fantastic fit for the Pittsburgh Steelers. Known for his strong arm and ability to make deep throws, Carr would bring an added dimension to Pittsburgh’s offense. Over the years, Carr has quietly put up impressive numbers, consistently throwing for over 4,000 yards per season. While he has yet to lead his team to significant playoff success, Carr’s individual performance has been solid, and he has proven himself to be a franchise quarterback.
For the Steelers, Carr’s arm strength and ability to attack defenses vertically would complement their offensive scheme. With playmakers like George Pickens and Najee Harris, Carr would have the tools needed to succeed. In addition to his on-field talent, Carr is also a strong leader, something the Steelers would benefit from as they look to develop their young core of players. Carr could bring a new energy to Pittsburgh and help the team take the next step toward competing for championships.
Jimmy Garoppolo: A Winner Who Knows How to Manage Games
While Jimmy Garoppolo may not have the flashy stats of Cousins or Carr, he is one of the most successful quarterbacks in recent years. Garoppolo has led the San Francisco 49ers to multiple playoff appearances, including a Super Bowl berth, and his ability to manage games has made him a valuable asset to any team. For the Steelers, Garoppolo’s style of play could be a perfect fit. He excels at making quick decisions, managing the clock, and executing a balanced offense.
Garoppolo’s leadership and poise in high-stakes situations would bring much-needed stability to the Steelers’ quarterback room. He’s not going to put up eye-popping numbers, but he can make the necessary throws and lead a team to victory. For a team like the Steelers, who rely on their defense and running game, Garoppolo would be a low-risk, high-reward option. He could help guide the Steelers back to the postseason while providing a steady hand at the helm.
How the Steelers Can Improve Their Quarterback Play
Regardless of which quarterback the Steelers target, it’s clear that improving their quarterback play is essential to their success in 2025. The Steelers have a solid foundation on defense, with playmakers like T.J. Watt and Minkah Fitzpatrick anchoring the unit. However, the offense will need to improve for Pittsburgh to be a true contender. The offensive line must continue to develop, ensuring that any quarterback has the protection needed to make plays.
Moreover, the Steelers need to build around their quarterback by enhancing their receiving corps and providing the necessary tools for success. With a quarterback like Cousins, Carr, or Garoppolo, the Steelers can focus on developing a balanced offense that can complement their elite defense. The right quarterback can unlock the potential of the Steelers’ offense, creating a balanced and dynamic team capable of challenging for the playoffs and beyond.
Conclusion
The Pittsburgh Steelers face an important decision regarding their quarterback position as they look ahead to the 2025 season. While Aaron Rodgers has been the most talked-about potential addition, the Steelers cannot afford to rely on the assumption that he will sign. If the Rodgers deal falls through, quarterbacks like Kirk Cousins, Derek Carr, and Jimmy Garoppolo should be at the top of Pittsburgh’s list. These quarterbacks offer stability, leadership, and a proven track record of success. With the right quarterback under center, the Steelers can continue to compete for championships and maintain their legacy as one of the NFL’s most storied franchises.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What are the Steelers’ main quarterback options if Aaron Rodgers doesn’t sign?
- How would Kirk Cousins fit into the Steelers’ offensive system?
- Why is Derek Carr a strong candidate for the Steelers?
- What makes Jimmy Garoppolo a good option for the Steelers?
- How would the Steelers’ offensive line impact their quarterback choice?
- Can the Steelers still make a Super Bowl run with a new quarterback in 2025?
- What role does the Steelers’ defense play in supporting their quarterback?
- How does the Steelers’ schedule affect their quarterback decision?
- Why is leadership important for the Steelers’ quarterback position?
- How do Steelers matchups against teams like the Ravens and Bengals affect their quarterback strategy?
You may also read: Recap of Phillies vs Diamondbacks Game
